Our 5 Favorite Paperlike Alternatives in 2025

iPads are quickly becoming one of the most popular options for students, professionals, and creatives. The convenience factor is hard to ignore, but so is losing the tactile experience of using a pencil and a sheet of paper. 

Many iPad users want the best of both worlds. If you’re looking for a product that replicates the feeling of paper, you’ve likely heard of Paperlike. It’s one of the most popular options out there, but it doesn’t check every box. 

More and more iPad users are searching for Paperlike alternatives.

What is Paperlike?

Price: $44.99 

Paperlike is a screen protector that mimics the feeling of writing or drawing on paper. Hence the name, Paperlike. 

It’s a big name in the iPad accessory world. The matte, anti-glare screen protector has lots of fans, but plenty of other iPad users are scratching their heads and wondering why it’s the go-to choice for a paper-like screen protector. 

Paperlike certainly feels like Paper, but there are other factors to consider. 

First and foremost, users complain about the precise and tedious installation process. If you don’t install the screen protector right the first time, you’re in trouble. And to make matters worse, Paperlike’s screen protector isn’t reusable because it uses adhesive that can’t be reapplied once removed. 

Then there’s the issue of wear and tear. Notetakers and digital artists soon discovered an unexpected side effect after using Paperlike for a few months — their Apple Pencil nib wore down much quicker than expected, leaving them with an extra expense. It’s no surprise that iPad users are on the hunt for the best Paperlike alternatives. 

Let’s dive a bit deeper into the most common criticisms of Paperlike.

Common issues & complaints 

• Application process. Notetakers are often frustrated by the difficult application process, which requires careful attention to detail and a dust-free environment. If dust finds its way underneath your screen, you’ll get bubbles. If your placement is slightly off, you’ll get bubbles. You get the picture — a lot can go wrong. 
• Apple Pencil longevity. One complaint stands out among the rest: plenty of Paperlike users say they have to replace their Apple Pencil tip every four to six months. This problem tends to only strike people who might use their iPads daily, like illustrators and graphic designers. However, it’s an important cost consideration, especially when daily iPad users can expect their Apple Pencil tip to last up to a year when used on the standard glass screen. 
• Dirt. Due to the textured surface, Paperlike is a prime candidate for dirt and debris buildup. It’s more difficult to keep a Paperlike screen clean than a standard tempered glass protector — something to bear in mind if the sight of dirt strikes fear into your heart. 
• Single use. Once it’s on, it’s on. You can remove Paperlike’s screen protector, but you’ll have to shell out for a new one. 
• Upfront cost. A two-pack of Paperlike screen protectors will set you back $44.99, a significant investment for a single-use product. Single screen protectors are more affordable, but since they are single-use and difficult to install, you’re more likely to need two, three, or four… 
• Wear and tear. Paperlike’s screen protector is covered in a layer of texture which creates the realistic paper feel. But as soon as you start using your stylus, the quality of the screen protector will degrade. In time, wear and tear will soften – or even remove entirely – some of the texture, making your grasp on that paper-like feeling tenuous at best. To regain it, you’ll need to buy another Paperlike screen protector. And another one. And another… 

Many note-takers feel disillusioned by the high cost, difficult application process, and single-use nature of Paperlike. That’s why we’ve found alternatives to suit every budget and preference. 

1. Rock Paper Pencil 

Best for: Removable & Reusable, A cohesive experience that considers stylus and screen

Cost: $44.99

Rock Paper Pencil was released in 2023, six years after Paperlike. Developers used that time to address some of the most common criticisms levied at the product. After careful prototyping and market research, they created the only paper-feel iPad screen protector that comes with ballpoint Apple Pencil tips. After all, there’s no point in having a paper-like screen if you’re using the same old Apple Pencil stylus. 

Here’s how the two components work together: 

• Nano-texture screen protector. The surface is infused with microscopic textured nodes that replicate the ‘tooth’ of fine-grain paper, providing you with an unbeatable level of friction and control. 
• Precision-engineered ballpoint tip. The ballpoint tip works seamlessly with the screen protector, delivering a subtle ‘bite’ that mimics the feeling of a traditional writing experience. 

This Paperlike alternative covers every base, including the issue of longevity. Whereas Paperlike is single-use, Rock Paper Pencil uses clever engineering to create a sustainable, reusable product. It’s fitted with a NanoCling technology that easily snaps onto and peels off your iPad screen. 

On top of that, the screen is matte and anti-glare, so the sun won’t stop you from taking important notes, drawing, or planning your next vacation. 

Overall, Rock Paper Pencil offers a complete pen-on-paper feeling that’s longer lasting and far more cohesive than Paperlike. 

Want to learn more? We’ve created an in-depth guide comparing Apple Pencil tips vs. Rock Paper Pencil tips. 

How it compares to Paperlike 

✅ Comparable cost

✅ Two additional Apple Pencil tip replacements 

✅ Reusable 

✅ Won’t destroy your Apple Pencil

2. KCT Paperfeel Screen Protector 

Best for: Protecting your paper-like screen with tempered glass

Buy here

Cost: $13.99

Most paper-feel screen protectors leave your iPad vulnerable, but KCT’s Paperfeel Screen Protector stops accidental bumps and drops from ruining your day. It combines a paper-like feel with tempered glass to give you an unbeatable experience. 

The protector is made from high-quality paper film imported from Japan, and we’ve got to admit, it feels just like paper. And an added bonus is the matte texture, which protects against perspiration marks and allows you to enjoy smudge-free note-taking. 

Thankfully, KCT Paperfeel comes with an Auto Alignment Kit. It includes an installation frame that has been refined and improved to ensure easier applications, but some notetakers still find bubbles underneath the screen protector. Then again, others say the installation process is a breeze. To smooth out any issues you might face, KCT has created a detailed installation video that describes all the key steps. 

Compared to Paperlike, KCT’s main selling point is its tempered glass finish. It’s also important to note that it’s marketed to digital painters and notetakers, suggesting it’s not specifically designed for handwriting. Still, as far as Paperlike alternatives go, it’s a worthy opponent. 

Want to explore the world of digital drawing but aren’t sure where to start? Check out 7 Tips for Making the Transition from Traditional Drawing to Digital.

How it compares to Paperlike 

✅ Auto Alignment Kit reduces the chance of air bubbles 

✅ Tempered glass protects your iPad 

✅ Offers a paper-like feel

✅ Less expensive

❌ Some users say it reduces touch-screen functionality 

❌ Still requires a tedious installation process

3. IPROKKO Magenetic Privacy Screen Protector 

Best for: Privacy while taking notes 

Buy here

Cost: $19.99

IPROKKO’s screen protector doesn’t claim to have a paper-like feel to it, but it’s still a worthy Paperlike alternative. We’ve thrown this option in for notetakers who want an added sense of privacy while taking notes, browsing the web, and chatting with friends.

The screen darkens when viewed from the side, stopping nosy neighbors from reading and stealing your information. If you take notes in class, on the bus, or in other high-traffic areas, this could be perfect for you. However, it’s important to remember that privacy screens are only effective when viewed from the side. In other words, it won’t stop people from peeping at your screen when you’re not in the room.  

Another nice touch is the anti-glare technology, which protects your eyes from some of the unpleasant side effects of too much screen time. 

The screen attaches to your iPad via magnets in just a few seconds. It’s ultra-thin, easy to clean, and compatible with Apple Pencil. And despite all these features, it doesn’t compromise your iPad’s touch sensitivity. 

It might not feel like paper, but it’s scratch-resistant. At least, that’s what IPROKKO says. But a quick Google search tells us that the screen’s glass hardness rating — which is 4H, by the way — is on the lower end of the scale, making it more prone to scratches than, for example, a screen with a 9H rating. 

How it compares to Paperlike 

✅ Scratch resistant 

✅ Effective privacy screen 

✅ Easy installation and removal 

✅ Less expensive

❌ Doesn’t feel like paper

4. Spigen PaperTouch Pro Matte Screen Protector 

Best for: A super thin, paper-like feel that retains your iPad’s typical touchscreen response

Buy here

Cost: $34.99

Spigen’s PaperTouch Pro offers a truly matte writing experience with just the right amount of stroke resistance. There’s absolutely no glare — you can take notes on the go, whether you’re on the bus, at the beach, or in the office. 

This protector was specifically designed for iPad Pro users, encouraging them to unlock their creativity on one of the most advanced iPad models to date. It responds to input from Apple Pencils and transforms your thoughts into digital handwriting in an instant.

A big advantage of PaperTouch Pro is the installation case. It guides you through the most important part of the process, making it easier than ever to avoid bubbles and achieve a smooth, level finish. 

A small but noticeable downside is that Spigen’s PaperTouch Screen Protector is made for Spigen iPad cases, meaning the precise cut-outs might seem a bit out of place with any other case.

Something else to consider is wear and tear. Some notetakers are surprised to find that their Apple Pencil tip wears out far quicker than expected, an issue that also affects notetakers who use Paperlike screen protectors. 

Last but not least, PaperTouch Pro is known for its strong hold. This is a big benefit — at least until you need to get it off.

It’s a good Paperlike alternative for notetakers who won’t miss their iPad’s glossy screen. Spigen’s protector is also a bit cheaper, and while the price drop won’t make you a millionaire overnight, it’s nice to see a more affordable option on the market. 

How it compares to Paperlike 

✅ Protects against scratches 

✅ Extremely anti-glare 

✅ Less expensive

❌ Cutouts designed for Spigen iPad cases

❌ Some notetakers say that Spigen’s screen protector wears down their Apple Pencil even faster than Paperlike does

5. Ocushield Anti Blue Light Screen Protector

Best for: People who suffer from (and want to prevent) eye strain

Buy here

Cost: $39.90

Ocushield is dedicated to protecting you from blue light. It doesn’t matter whether you’re a notetaker, digital illustrator, or big-time gamer — you need to avoid it as much as possible. 

Most digital devices, including smartphones, computers, and, you guessed it, iPads, emit blue light. Blue light can damage light-sensitive cells in the retina, and can even trick your brain into thinking it’s daytime when it’s not. This is a big problem for night owl notetakers, turning their harmless hobby into a much bigger issue. 

Ocushield is an effective solution. It was designed and developed by Optometrists in the UK and blocks up to 99% of blue light. 

When the protector is installed, you can enjoy headache-free note-taking sessions with crystal-clear picture quality. The screen is even made from tempered glass, protecting your iPad in the event of scratches or unexpected bumps.  

Ocushield might not offer the most paper-like feeling, but it solves lots of other problems. 

Who’d have thought that a Paperlike alternative could be a Class 1 Medical Device? Ocushield is an ergonomic addition to the market, considering a new angle of the human experience. And it’s verified by the MHRA and FDA, so it’s definitely legit. 

On a more practical note: this screen protector comes with an applicator tray and also has a 100-day guarantee. If you aren’t happy with the product, you can simply send it back.

How it compares to Paperlike 

✅ Blue light filter

✅ 100-day money back guarantee

✅ Class 1 Medical Device 

✅ Less expensive

❌ Doesn’t feel like paper

Best Paperlike Alternative: Rock Paper Pencil

While some digital notetakers prefer Paperlike, we don’t believe the hype. There are too many glaring problems, such as how much the textured screen protector wears down Apple Pencil nibs and the tedious installation process.

And of course there is the issue of Paperlike being a single-use product. Once you remove it, it’s gone forever and you’ll have to buy another and throw your old one in the bin. That doesn’t seem very eco-friendly. 

Rock Paper Pencil is a smarter, more thoughtful alternative. It includes two ballpoint-style Apple Pencil tips that are wear-resistant and designed to work seamlessly with our reusable matte screen protector. Together, they recreate the tactile friction of pen on paper, without the downsides.

Instead of using adhesive, Rock Paper Pencil attaches with static cling. That means you can easily apply, remove, and reattach it whenever you want—no residue, no waste.

→ If you’re looking for a reusable, durable, and better-designed Paperlike alternative, Rock Paper Pencil is it.

Frequently asked questions about Paperlike alternatives 

1. Are these Paperlike alternatives good for writing and drawing? 

Yes! Paperlike isn’t the only effective matte screen protector out there. Thousands of notetakers, illustrators, and graphic designers use Paperlike alternatives like Rock Paper Pencil, Ocushield, and KCT. 

Rock Paper Pencil is especially good for writing and drawing because it looks at both sides of the problem. Not only does it come with a screen protector that feels just like paper, but it also includes two Apple Pencil replacement tips. The built-in textured nodes complement the screen protector, creating realistic friction when you write or draw. 

2. Can paper-like/paper-feel screen protectors ruin my Apple Pencil? 

This is a common complaint. When the nib of your Apple Pencil rubs against your matte screen protector, it creates friction. Apple designed its tips to work on laminated glass, not a textured surface. Textured matte screen protectors like Paperlike and other competitors will always cause friction, meaning your Apple Pencil tip will wear down far quicker than usual. 

Longevity isn’t an issue for Rock Paper Pencil because our ballpoint Apple Pencil tips are designed to handle texture. And they’re also designed to work perfectly with the screen protector — a win all around.  

3. Which screen protector feels most like paper? 

It’s open to debate, but this isn’t something that the top brands struggle with — it’s pretty common to find a matte screen protector that feels like paper. However, very few are also reusable like Rock Paper Pencil.

4. Will these screen protectors affect my screen quality? 

The jury is out — some people say that matte screen protectors don’t have a noticeable effect on the quality, whereas others have noticed a significant difference. This problem seems to crop up a lot with Paperlike. Don’t take our word for it, check out the reviews. 

5. Are any of these Paperlike alternatives reusable? 

Many Paperlike alternatives aren’t reusable, but one is! Rock Paper Pencil uses NanoCling technology to seamlessly stick to your iPad screen and easily peel off when not necessary.